The 4 PCI Compliance Levels Explained

Understanding where your business falls in these levels is crucial for compliance, credibility, and customer trust.

What Is PCI Compliance?

PCI compliance refers to meeting the requirements of the PCI DSS, a set of global security standards established by Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover, and JCB. These standards are designed to secure cardholder data and reduce the risk of fraud.

Any business that stores, processes, or transmits cardholder information must comply. Non-compliance can result in steep fines, damaged reputation, or even losing the ability to accept card payments.

It’s important to note that the PCI compliance level assigned to your business depends on the number of card transactions you process annually. In short: higher transaction volumes mean stricter requirements.

Why PCI Compliance Levels Exist

Not all businesses are alike. A small family-run coffee shop handling a few hundred transactions per week doesn’t pose the same risk as a massive global e-commerce platform processing millions daily. PCI DSS compliance levels are tiered to balance the level of oversight with the risk involved.

These levels aren’t just about transaction volume. If your business experiences a data breach, you may automatically be elevated to a higher compliance level regardless of size.

To put it simply:

• Level 1: For the largest merchants or those with prior breaches.
• Level 2: For mid-sized businesses.
• Level 3: For smaller but growing e-commerce merchants.
• Level 4: For the smallest businesses.

PCI Compliance Level 1

This is the most rigorous level and requires significant investment in security infrastructure.

• Criteria: Businesses processing over 6 million transactions per year across all channels, or any business that has suffered a major breach.
• Requirements:
  • Annual on-site security assessment conducted by a Qualified Security Assessor (QSA).
  • Quarterly network scans by an Approved Scanning Vendor (ASV).
  • Extensive documentation, policies, and security testing.
• Who it applies to: Global retailers, international airlines, large e-commerce giants, and financial institutions.

PCI Compliance Level 2

Level 2 still requires strong compliance, but with fewer reporting obligations than Level 1.

• Criteria: Businesses processing 1 million to 6 million transactions per year.
• Requirements:
  • Annual Self-Assessment Questionnaire (SAQ) or QSA validation depending on card brand.
  • Quarterly ASV scans.
• Who it applies to: Mid-sized businesses like franchise chains, regional retailers, and hospitality providers.

PCI Compliance Level 3

Level 3 is often where businesses start to feel the complexity of PCI compliance as their customer base scales.

• Criteria: Businesses processing 20,000 to 1 million e-commerce transactions annually.
• Requirements:
  • Annual SAQ.
  • Quarterly ASV scans.
• Who it applies to: Growing e-commerce businesses, subscription platforms, SaaS companies, and digital marketplaces.

PCI Compliance Level 4

Though Level 4 has the lightest requirements, small businesses should not underestimate the importance of compliance. Breaches at this level can still be devastating.

• Criteria: Businesses processing fewer than 20,000 e-commerce transactions annually or up to 1 million total transactions across all channels.
• Requirements:
  • Annual SAQ.
  • Quarterly scans may be required depending on the card brand.
• Who it applies to: Small businesses, independent online sellers, restaurants, and local service providers.

Comparing the PCI Compliance Levels

The differences between the levels of PCI compliance can be summarized as follows:

• Transaction volume: Level 1 is the largest, Level 4 the smallest.
• Audit requirements: Level 1 requires an on-site QSA assessment; Levels 2–4 typically rely on SAQs.
• Risk: The higher the level, the greater the risk and responsibility.

Even if you’re a small merchant at Level 4, failing to comply can result in penalties just as damaging as for larger businesses.

How to Determine Your PCI Compliance Level

To figure out your compliance level:

1. Calculate annual transaction volume across all sales channels.
2. Check card brand guidelines (Visa, Mastercard, etc.), as definitions may vary slightly.
3. Consult with your acquiring bank or payment processor for confirmation.
4. A breach may escalate you to Level 1 requirements regardless of volume.

Working with trusted payment processors or an ISO payment processing partner can simplify this process.

Best Practices for Achieving PCI Compliance

No matter your level, compliance is an ongoing task. Here are some best practices:

• Use strong encryption and tokenization for all cardholder data.
• Regularly patch and update software and POS systems.
• Train employees to identify phishing and social engineering attempts.
• Partner with payment processing solutions that are PCI compliant by default.
• Conduct continuous monitoring and network scans.

For small businesses, tools like dual pricing (offering discounts for cash payments) can reduce card transactions altogether, thereby lowering compliance burdens.

Global Considerations for PCI Compliance Levels

PCI DSS is a global framework, but regional regulations add another layer of responsibility. For example:

• In the EU, PCI DSS requirements may overlap with GDPR data protection laws.
• In the U.S., businesses must also consider state-level privacy laws like the CCPA.
• In Asia-Pacific, financial hubs like Singapore and Hong Kong enforce stricter oversight for card data storage.

By knowing your compliance level, following best practices, and working with trusted providers, you can reduce risks, build customer trust, and avoid penalties. At the end of the day, compliance means protecting your business and your customers.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What are PCI compliance levels?

They are categories that determine a business’s obligations based on annual card transaction volume.

How many PCI DSS compliance levels are there?

There are four levels, ranging from Level 1 for the largest merchants to Level 4 for smaller businesses.

Who sets the PCI compliance levels?

The PCI Security Standards Council (PCI SSC), created by major card networks, defines and enforces them.

Do small businesses need PCI compliance?

Yes, even Level 4 merchants must comply by completing SAQs and security scans.

What happens if a business is not PCI compliant?

Non-compliance may result in fines, penalties, increased transaction fees, or termination of merchant accounts.

Can PCI compliance levels change?

Yes, if a business grows in transaction volume or experiences a data breach, it may be moved to a higher level.

References

IT Governance. (2022, September 6). A guide to the 4 PCI DSS compliance levels. IT Governance EU. https://www.itgovernance.eu/blog/en/a-guide-to-the-4-pci-dss-compliance-levels

PCIPolicyPortal.com. (n.d.). PCI merchant levels 1–4 and compliance requirements – Visa & Mastercard. PCIPolicyPortal. https://pcipolicyportal.com/what-is-pci/merchants/

Tidal Commerce. (n.d.). What are ISO payments? Everything you need to know. Tidal Commerce. https://www.tidalcommerce.com/learn/iso-payment-processing